Table of Contents

Have you been thinking of investing in the Toledo property market? We don’t blame you. Over the past two years, the Toledo market has been red HOT. But that doesn’t make investing in the Glass City easy. But to get you started and give you the insight you need to become a successful real estate investor, we’ve put together a step-by-step Toledo real estate investment guide.

Here’s what you’re going to get: 

  • Data telling you exactly WHY Toledo is one of the nation’s best markets for cash flow AND appreciation.
  • Our favorite neighborhoods for investing (collated from 10+ years of Toledo investment property experience).
  • Our TOP tips for investors new to Toledo.
  • Insight on how to get off-market real estate opportunities in Toledo.

The Toledo real estate market is ripe for investment. Real estate investors are finding rental properties with strong cash flow and 8-10% cap rates. But this hot market won’t last forever. Property prices are increasing faster than rental rates, which is going to ultimately condense cap rates.

Don’t be the real estate investor who sat on the sideline and watched yet another golden opportunity pass you by.

Toledo continues to be one of the more affordable housing markets in the United States. Have you ever wanted to buy a rental property for the same amount you would spend on a semi-luxury vehicle? Well, you can in Toledo, OH.

Why is the Toledo Real Estate So Cheap: The Historical Background

As of 1965, manufacturing durable goods was the most significant contributor to Toledo’s economy, leaving it vulnerable. Unfortunately, as globalization escalated, manufacturing industries gradually began leaving the Midwest and outsourced to more affordable labor markets. This trend resulted in a major increase in Toledo’s unemployment, a huge hit to the city’s economy, and ultimately a decline in Toledo’s population.

In 1970, Toledo’s population peaked at about 380,000 people. As of 2024, its population is down to 262,336. This decline resulted in more houses than households, leaving many homes vacant or in disrepair. Fortunately, Toledo’s economy is rebounding, its population is holding steady, and there’s an opportunity for real estate investors.

The city’s shift from a manufacturing-centric economy to a more diversified one, including healthcare and technology, promises a more stable job market and, consequently, a steady demand for housing.

Why Invest in Toeldo Real Estate: Key Investment Market Indicators

Interest rates have been high, impacting nearly every housing market nationwide. When interest rates go up, housing affordability goes down. However, in markets like Toledo, which is incredibly affordable, interest rates seem to have no impact.

Toledo’s housing market is stronger than it’s been in decades. According to Rocket Mortgage, housing prices increased 7.6% year-over-year, and Redfin’s data reflects an even more significant increase of 17% year-over-year. The median home price in Toledo is now just $117,000.

With a housing affordability index of 226, Toledo housing is among the most affordable nationwide. Residents can afford their rent and mortgages. Extreme housing affordability means that the real estate market has plenty of growth potential in both home prices and rental rates, which is a positive sign for real estate investing.

Low inventory, which was once unheard of in Toledo, is driving the real estate market.

What attracts real estate investors most to Toledo is that it’s one of the most affordable markets in the country. Home prices are far below the national average, and cap rates are high. Attainable entry prices make it possible for those who never thought they could afford to invest to get into real estate.

Why Did Ohio Cashflow Choose Investment Property in Toledo?

Toledo, OH, isn’t a sexy real estate market. We didn’t choose to build a business here because we were after high appreciation. Just like other investors, Ohio Cashflow chose Toledo because it saw an opportunity in Toledo’s affordability and high rental returns. Investment properties in the right neighborhoods offer return rates that are unheard of in other markets.

Unlike appreciation, cash flow is reliable, and we can calculate it accurately. We don’t believe in real estate investing based on speculation. Our properties are selected and renovated so that even if they never appreciate in value, the investor still gets a fantastic return. Any appreciation on top is just an added bonus.

Investing the Toledo Real Estate Market: Your Step-by-Step Guide

Investing in the Toledo property market presents a fantastic opportunity for real estate investors, but that doesn’t mean you should just dive into the market. To be a successful personal investor, you need a deep understanding of the city, demographics, neighborhoods, and properties you buy.

Thorough research is essential before investing in any real estate market, especially in a city like Toledo, where economic and housing dynamics can vary widely across different neighborhoods. Toledo’s real estate market has experienced steady growth, with even greater price increases over the past few years. Current market conditions show a trend of increasing demand for housing and investment, driven by Toledo’s strengthening job market and economic development initiatives.

Projections for Toledo’s real estate market are optimistic. declared Toledo the hottest real estate market of 2024. Experts predict continued growth in property values and rental demand, particularly in up-and-coming neighborhoods. Analyzing economic indicators such as employment rates, income levels, and population growth helps you understand the market’s potential while setting realistic expectations. The Toledo Regional Chamber of Commerce provides valuable insights and updates.

Step Two: Narrow Down Your Target Neighborhoods

When investing in the Toledo real estate market, selecting the right neighborhood is crucial for maximizing your return on investment. This step involves conducting a thorough analysis of various neighborhoods to identify those that offer the best investment opportunities. Key factors to consider include:

  • Local economic stability
  • Demand for rentals
  • Property values
  • Potential for appreciation.
  • Crime rates
  • Available housing stock
  • Local amenities.

Look for neighborhoods with signs of growth or regeneration, such as new businesses moving in, infrastructure development, and increasing population trends. These indicators can signal a rising demand for housing and the potential for property value appreciation.

B-Class properties represent an attractive investment option in Toledo’s real estate market. These properties are typically located in good areas that are not the most expensive but still offer strong rental demand. They are often characterized by their stability, lower vacancy rates, and appealing balance of rental income to purchase price.

Investing in B-Class properties allows you to target a tenant base that is generally reliable and financially stable, reducing the risks of frequent turnover and non-payment. These properties strike an ideal balance, offering the benefits of both A-Class and C-Class properties by providing a mix of quality, affordability, and investment security.

Ohio Cashflow, with its extensive experience in the Toledo market, has identified several neighborhoods that are best for real estate investing. Toledo’s neighborhoods, like West Toledo and Old Orchard, offer stable environments with a strong sense of community, making them attractive to renters seeking quality living spaces without the premium price tag of luxury areas. These neighborhoods feature well-maintained homes, good schools, and convenient access to amenities, contributing to their desirability and helping maintain steady property values.

Step Three: Start Looking for Properties

Once you have identified your target neighborhoods in Toledo, the next step is looking for potential investment properties. This phase is critical and requires a strategic approach to uncover the best opportunities that align with your investment goals and budget.

The best real estate opportunities in Toled are off-market properties. These properties are not listed on the Multiple Listing Service (MLS) and, as such, are less exposed to the general investing public. While the MLS is a valuable resource for real estate listings, properties are overpriced for investors, with listings aimed at homebuyers. Homebuyers are always willing to pay a higher price than real estate investors.

The advantage of off-market properties is that they can often be acquired at below-market prices, with less competition from other buyers. Off-market properties provide a better deal for investors because the seller is usually motivated to sell quickly due to personal circumstances, financial distress, or the desire to avoid the hassles of a traditional sale process.

Strategies for finding off-market properties include:

  • Networking with local real estate agents, property managers, and investors.
  • Joining real estate investment groups.
  • Direct outreach to property owners.
  • Craigslist.
  • Building relationships with local attorneys and estate planners.

For an easier solution to finding off-market investment properties, contact Ohio Cashflow, Toledo’s leading turnkey real estate investment properties provider.

Step Four: Analyze Current and Potential Income Potential

After identifying your target neighborhoods and beginning your property search, the next crucial step is to analyze the financial aspects of your potential real estate investments in Toledo.

To effectively evaluate the financial prospects of real estate investments in Toledo, consider the following key factors:

  • Repair Costs:
    • Conduct thorough property inspections to estimate repair and renovation costs.
    • Include these estimates in the overall investment budget to assess affordability and ROI.
  • Vacancy Costs:
    • Analyze local market vacancy rates and average rental turnover times.
    • Estimate a budget for potential vacancies to ensure financial stability.
  • Rental Rates:
    • Research competitive rental rates in the target neighborhood for similar properties.
    • Consider property features and market demand to set realistic yet profitable rent prices.
  • Total Returns After Expenses:
    • Calculate net income by subtracting all operating expenses, including mortgage, taxes, maintenance, and vacancy costs, from the total rental income.
    • Ensure the final figure aligns with your investment goals and ROI expectations.
  • Tax Implications and Incentives:
    • Understand property-related taxes and identify potential deductions and incentives.
    • Consult with a tax professional to optimize tax benefits and enhance overall returns.
  • Long-term Growth and Exit Strategy:
    • Assess the property’s appreciation potential and the market’s long-term outlook.
    • Develop an exit strategy that aligns with your investment objectives, whether for capital gains or income generation.
  • Risk Assessment and Management:
    • Identify potential risks, including market volatility and regulatory changes.
    • Implement risk management strategies, such as obtaining appropriate insurance and maintaining a contingency fund.

By systematically addressing these aspects, you can make an informed decision about the viability and profitability of real estate investments in Toledo, ensuring a comprehensive approach to analyzing current and potential income potential.

Step Five: Offer, Negotiate, and Close

The final step in securing a real estate investment in Toledo is to make an offer, negotiate effectively, and close the deal. When making an offer, it’s essential to stick within your budget and aim for properties that meet your desired return levels. Your offer should be based on a thorough analysis of the property’s value, potential income, and required investments in repairs and upgrades.

During negotiations, utilize the insights gained from your market research and financial analysis to argue your offer and negotiate terms that align with your investment goals. It’s important to remain adaptable and firm on the key financial parameters governing your investment decision. Being prepared to walk away is a powerful stance in negotiation.

Once you have successfully negotiated the terms, the next step is to close on the property. Closing involves finalizing the financial transaction, transferring property titles, and completing any necessary legal paperwork. While financing options are available, Toledo real estate investors should purchase in cash. Cash transactions can expedite the closing process, reduce risks associated with loan dependence, and potentially secure a better purchase price due to the certainty and speed of the transaction for the seller.

Step Six: Renovate and Lease

After acquiring a property, the following steps are renovation and leasing, each critical for maximizing your investment’s potential in Toledo’s real estate market.

A rental property renovation aims to enhance the property’s value and appeal to potential tenants without overspending. Avoid over-upgrading; instead, focus on making cost-effective improvements that increase the property’s durability and functionality. Choose materials and finishes that offer a good balance between cost, durability, and appeal. For example, instead of opting for high-end countertops in a mid-market rental, consider more durable and less expensive alternatives that still look attractive.

Evaluate each property component carefully to determine whether it needs replacement or can be refreshed or repaired. Not every element needs to be brand new, especially if it doesn’t significantly contribute to the property’s rental value or operational efficiency. Upgrading only what is necessary helps to control costs and ensures a better return on investment.

When you are ready to lease your Toledo rental property, setting the right price and finding the right tenant are paramount. Price the property competitively to attract a steady stream of potential tenants without undercutting your potential income. Use market research to understand the rental rates for comparable properties in the area. When determining a rental rate, factor in:

  • Location
  • Property size
  • Amenities
  • Finishes

Do not overlook tenant screening. A reliable tenant reduces the risks of rental income loss, property damage, and legal issues. Implement a thorough screening process that includes credit checks, employment verification, rental history, and references.

Step Seven: Ongoing Property Management

Effective property management is crucial for maintaining and enhancing the value of your real estate investment in Toledo. It involves a range of activities, from tenant relations to maintenance and financial oversight. Here are some major tips for successful property management:

  1. Regular Maintenance and Inspections
  2. Tenant Relations
  3. Financial Management
  4. Legal Compliance
  5. Market Analysis

Engaging a professional property management company can significantly simplify the responsibilities of a real estate investor. Our team has specialized knowledge and experience in managing Toledo rental properties, leading to more effective and efficient management practices. We help you save money through our relationships with contractor vendors and reduce the burden of being a landlord.

Elevate Your Toledo Real Estate Investing Journey with OzRealty

Real estate investors have their sights set on the Toledo market for good reason. Over the course of 2024, home prices are expected to increase by over 8%, but what attracts real estate investors is the cash flow. Rental properties in Toledo are known to generate between 8-10% cap rates.

Almost anyone can become a landlord in Toledo, OH as real estate here is some of the most affordable in the nation. However, the work doesn’t stop after acquisition. Actually, that is when it really begins. A professional and personal investor can simplify their investment property experience and maximize their real estate portfolio with the help of a professional real estate management company.

At Oz Realty, it’s our job to protect our client’s interest in their rental property and help them grow their portfolio. We make it possible for anyone to invest in Toledo, no matter where you live. Contact Oz Realty to discover how we can help you build a successful portfolio that generates passive income for years to come.

About the Author

Kelsey Heath

Kelsey Heath is a real estate content specialist with an extensive background in residential, industrial, and commercial property. She has been involved in the industry for a decade as a professional and personal investor, gaining a deep understanding of the market and trends. With a passion for written communication, Kelsey loves helping people understand the sometimes-complicated concepts behind real estate and is now a sought-out guest and ghostwriter.

More about Kelsey