If you’re a rental property owner looking to maximize your returns, you’re not alone. Every investor in the rental property market shares the same goal: to generate significant income while minimizing expenses. It’s only natural to want your property to make a substantial profit while finding ways to save on costs.

Table of Contents

An important part of any smart strategy for rental property investments starts with your rate of return calculation, which helps you analyze a consistent profit and make wise real estate investment decisions. However, several variables can impact your net operating income, affecting your profitability.

Owning highly profitable residential real estate is not just about crunching numbers and calculating returns – it’s about adopting a holistic approach that combines financial analysis, market knowledge, and effective management techniques.

Additionally, we’ll delve into the role of Toledo property management in maximizing your rental returns and how they can optimize your operations, enhance tenant satisfaction, and ultimately boost your bottom line.

A woman with positive net operating income statement.

What Is A Good Return On Investment for Your Rental Property?

If you are new to owning rental property, you’re probably wondering what a good return on investment (ROI) is. Well, there isn’t a one-size-fits-all answer to this question, but generally speaking, in our Toledo real estate market (where we benefit from huge cash returns), an 8–12% ROI is considered good. However, this number can vary depending on various factors, such as:

  • Property purchase price
  • Mortgage costs, including your down payment, closing costs, and monthly payments
  • Rental income
  • Occupancy and vacancy rates
  • Operating expenses
  • How long you’ve owned the property (the longer you own, the higher your ROI should be)

The Formula for ROI

It is important to understand that rental income alone does not determine profitability. When evaluating rental properties’ profitability, understanding the formula for return on investment (ROI) is essential. It’s a formula that helps determine if a rental property is worth the investment. ROI is calculated by dividing the net profit generated from the property by the total investment cost and expressing it as a percentage.

Let’s consider a rental property with a purchase price of $60,000. After accounting for expenses such as mortgage payments, property management fees, and maintenance costs, the property generates an annual net profit of $5,000.

We use the formula: ROI = (Net Profit / Total Investment) x 100 to calculate the ROI.

In this case, the net profit is $5,000, and the total investment is $60,000.

Plugging these values into the formula, we get ROI = ($5,000 / $60,000) x 100 = 8.3%.

This means that the ROI for the Toledo rental property is 8.3%. It indicates the return generated relative to the initial investment of $60,000.

Regularly reviewing your rental property’s cash flow and calculating current ROI can help you make informed decisions about your investments, identify areas for improvement, and ensure long-term profitability.

Increasing profitability of real estate investment property.

How Variables Impact Net Operating Income

Net Operating Income (NOI) is an essential measure of a rental property’s financial performance, reflecting income generated after deducting operating expenses. Understanding which variables influence NOI is crucial for investors looking to maximize returns and make informed decisions, so let’s explore these variables.

Annual Rental Income

Annual Rental Income represents the gross total rental payments received from tenants over a year. Rental rates, occupancy levels, market conditions, and property management practices impact the annual rental income. Setting competitive rental rates, maintaining high occupancy, staying informed about market trends, and implementing effective property management strategies are key to maximizing rental income and ultimately boosting the property’s NOI and overall profitability.

Vacancy Rate and Turnover

A low vacancy rate translates to higher profits, while a high vacancy rate significantly reduces annual rental income, resulting in a lower NOI. That’s why we emphasize minimizing vacancies to ensure a profitable investment experience.

So how do we minimize vacancies? By employing a reliable property management company like Oz Realty. Our team takes care of every aspect of tenant relationships, from targeted advertising to tenant screening, ensuring that your property attracts high-quality tenants all without you having to lift a finger.

Operating Expenses

Operating expenses in real estate include property taxes, insurance, maintenance and repairs, property management fees, utilities, and other costs associated with regularly running and maintaining the property. Higher expenses eat into the profitability of your rental property. By effectively managing operating expenses through cost-saving measures, competitive insurance rates, efficient maintenance, and smart property management, investors can maximize the NOI and enhance the property’s profitability.

Financing Costs

If the property is financed, the interest rate, loan terms, and associated financing costs will impact the NOI. Higher interest rates or expensive financing options increase expenses and reduce NOI.

We recommend limiting your financing to no more than 50% of a property’s value for investment security. You can lower financing costs and increase cash flow by carrying less debt and being strategic with your loans. However, loans can be valuable for portfolio maximization, allowing leverage and growth opportunities. Find the right balance between financing and cash flow to optimize your rental property investments and total investment portfolio.

Property Appreciation

Toledo is not a hot market, but it steadily appreciates above the inflation rate each year, which means investors can rely on Toledo as a stable and dependable market for their investments. Toledo is the perfect investment market for investors who want a great rent and cash flow return. The real estate market in Toledo has shown promising growth. This positive trend has boosted property values.

Property appreciation impacts NOI because as property values rise, rental property owners increase rental rates, resulting in higher rental income and a higher NOI.

Property Taxes

Property taxes are levies imposed by local governments on properties within their jurisdiction. Property taxes are an expense that’s not within our control as property managers or investors but should be considered when evaluating a rental property’s profitability. The best time to consider property taxes is when buying a new investment. Make sure you calculate property taxes and understand your obligated expense.

Capital Expenditures

Significant expenses that add value to a property are classified as capital expenses. These include major renovations, new appliances, or repairs such as a roof replacement and can temporarily impact the NOI.

While these expenses may initially decrease the NOI, they can also enhance the property’s value and potential rental income in the long term. Major expenses are required to maintain or improve the property’s value over the long term.

Economic Conditions

When the Toledo economy is thriving, job opportunities are abundant, leading to an influx of people relocating to the region. As more individuals move to an area seeking employment, the demand for housing naturally increases. Strong economic conditions contribute to higher income and, therefore, higher profitability.

Market Competition

The level of competition from other rental properties in the area can affect your ability to attract tenants and set rental rates. If the market is saturated with available rentals, it may be harder to maintain high occupancy rates and rental income. In Toledo, the demand for rental properties is consistently strong, with nearly 50% of the city’s residents being renters. Therefore, the presence of market competition can work in your favor. The high demand for rental properties results in a stable cash flow because there’s a steady pool of prospective tenants seeking available rentals.

Calculate ROI and limit annual operating expenses.

Limit Expenses to Maximize Return on Rent

Limiting expenses is a smart approach to maximizing rent because it directly impacts the profitability of your rental property. Managing and maintaining investment properties with a budget in mind is pivotal to achieving the maximum return on investment. But how exactly can you minimize expenses without compromising the quality or value of your property?

Keep an eye on variable costs such as utilities and insurance to ensure unnecessary expenses do not eat away profits. Ultimately, limiting expenses must be achieved while ensuring that the property remains safe, attractive, and fit for purpose.

Here are some strategies you can implement to limit expenses:

Shop Around for Insurance

While appropriate coverage is important for protecting your investment, ensuring you’re not overpaying for insurance is equally crucial. Insurance premiums vary significantly among insurance companies, even for the same coverage. By comparing quotes from multiple insurers, you can identify competitive offers and the best deal rates to save money on your insurance costs. Even if you only save a hundred dollars a year, finding the best insurance deal is worth your time.

Work with Property Managers Who Have Strong Relationships

Rental property investing is a long-term game. It’s a marathon, not a sprint. Developing relationships with the right and trusted property managers ensures profitability in the long run. But how do Toledo property managers help lower your expenses?

At Oz Realty, we’ve established a network of vetted and reliable tradespeople. This strong alliance assures cost-effective and reliable solutions for all repair and maintenance tasks and guarantees top-tier workmanship. The competitive pricing offered by our tradespeople translates into substantial savings for our investors.

We oversee over 300 multiple properties, allowing us to negotiate bulk discounts and preferred rates from tradespeople and service providers. By consolidating our maintenance and repair needs across our portfolio of properties, we pass on our cost savings to investors. These reduced costs contribute to our investors’ bottom line by minimizing expenses and maximizing rental income.

By choosing Oz Realty, you’re selecting more than just a real estate service; you’re gaining access to an extensive network committed to amplifying your investment’s potential while minimizing costs.

Limit Vacancy Rates with Great Management

One essential aspect of managing rental units is maintaining a low vacancy rate. Vacancies mean loss of income, property deterioration, and high turnover costs. Avoid these costs by enlisting the help of a professional property management company like Oz Realty to help you attract and retain high-quality tenants hands-free and worry-free. We handle tenant screening, marketing, rent collection, and maintenance requests, ensuring that your property is always in top condition and that tenants are happy to renew their leases.

Real estate investors maximizing cash on cash return.

How Do I Maximize My ROI On My Rental Property?

Increasing your rental property’s return on investment (ROI) is undoubtedly your top priority as an investor. While there are many ways to accomplish this, one important aspect we shouldn’t overlook is the benefit of skilled property management like Oz Realty.

Utilizing a professional property management company offers numerous advantages that contribute to maximizing ROI.

Rental Market Analysis

Oz Realty conducts thorough market research to determine optimal rental rates for the property and sets competitive rental prices that maximize income while minimizing vacancies.

Tenant Screening

Oz Realty employs thorough screening processes, including background checks, credit history analysis, income verification, and rental history verification. By placing reliable and responsible tenants in properties, we reduce the risk of late payments, property damage, and evictions, ensuring consistent cash flow.

Effective Marketing and Advertising

Oz Realty uses online listings, professional photography, virtual tours, and other techniques to showcase the property’s best features. Effective marketing helps minimize vacancies, ensuring a steady stream of rental income.

Timely Rent Collection

Property management companies handle rent collection on behalf of property owners, enforce lease agreements, and pursue appropriate legal action if necessary. This ensures property owners receive their rental income on time and minimizes the risk of late or missed payments.

Property Maintenance and Repairs

Well-maintained properties attract and retain tenants, ensuring steady rental income. Property management companies like Oz Realty coordinate regular property inspections, handle maintenance requests, and promptly address any repairs or issues. By staying proactive and responsive, we preserve the property’s value and keep tenants satisfied, minimizing turnover and vacancy periods while reducing investor risk.

Cost-Effective Vendor Relationships

Oz Realty takes pride in establishing cost-effective vendor relationships that benefit property owners. Through our extensive industry connections and expertise, we have built strong partnerships with reliable vendors, contractors, and suppliers. These relationships enable us to negotiate favorable rates for property repairs, maintenance, and other services. By doing so, we minimize expenses for our clients and ensure top-notch workmanship and quality service.

Financial Reporting and Analysis

Property management companies provide detailed financial reporting to property owners, including income statements, expense reports, and rent rolls. At Oz Realty, we understand the importance of transparent and detailed financial reporting for property owners. We utilize AppFolio, a property management software, to provide comprehensive financial reports. These reports include income statements, expense reports, and rent rolls, giving our investors valuable insights into their property’s financial performance.

Real estate investors staying updated with legal laws regarding real estate investing.

Property management companies stay up-to-date with local, state, and federal regulations related to rental properties. At Oz Realty, we take compliance with legal regulations seriously. We stay abreast of local, state, and federal laws related to rental properties so that our clients don’t have to worry about costly penalties or legal disputes. From fair housing laws to landlord-tenant regulations and property safety codes, we ensure full adherence to all legal requirements.

Are you ready to maximize profitability on your rental property? Let Oz Realty help you.

Maximize profitability with Oz Realty’s expert property management services. From tenant acquisition to rent collection, maintenance, and financial management, we ensure your asset is efficiently managed. Contact us today for the returns you deserve.

About the Author

Kelsey Heath

Kelsey Heath is a real estate content specialist with an extensive background in residential, industrial, and commercial property. She has been involved in the industry for a decade as a professional and personal investor, gaining a deep understanding of the market and trends. With a passion for written communication, Kelsey loves helping people understand the sometimes-complicated concepts behind real estate and is now a sought-out guest and ghostwriter.

More about Kelsey